Skip to main content
Back to search
13900 Old Cutler Rd, Palmetto Bay, photo 1 of 20
For sale
1 / 20

$3.4M

13900 Old Cutler Rd

FARMERS ACRES, Palmetto Bay, FL 33158

Listing courtesy of BHHS EWM Realty · Drew Kern · 305-329-7744

4 bd 3.5 ba 2,789 sq ft

About this home

If you’re wondering if a true Old Florida home still exists, complete with a lush tropical native and edible landscape, you need to see this property. It’s almost an acre of land surrounded by multimillion dollar homes on historic Old Cutler Road, next to the prestigious Pinecrest neighborhood. You’ll know you’ve arrived when you see the distinctive wall along Old Cutler built from native limestone boulders. Inside the enclave there’s a midcentury gem of a main house with original quarry tile and red oak floors, a working fireplace, vaulted beam and tongue-and-groove ceilings, a spacious covered back porch and a carport. Behind the main house and overlooking the pool sits a 2-story structure built in 2006 that includes a cabana bathroom and a garage with high ceilings to accommodate a boat or several cars. Above it is a charming 900-square-foot studio apartment that looks out into the treetops. Along with underground power lines, the property gets city water but also has 2 private wells connected to sprinklers. With a history of only two owners in 73 years, the enclave is recently refreshed and ready for you to move right in. Come see!

Features

  • 4-car garage
  • Impact windows

Details

Type
House
Year built
1953
Roof
Ask your agent
Insurers ask about the roof's age.
HOA
None listed
Property taxes
$8,632/yr
Taxes usually change after a sale in Florida.
Flood zone
AE,X
Higher-risk flood area. Lenders require flood insurance.
Lot
38,768 sq ft
Listed
Sep 29, 2026
MLS #
A12096724

Storm protection: Impact windows. These can lower your insurance cost.

What this home really costs each month

The mortgage, plus property tax as it will be after you buy, insurance for this home's roof and age, flood insurance if a lender requires it, and the HOA. Move any slider to use your own numbers.

The rate starts at 6.5% as an example, not today's rate. Move it to the rate your lender quotes you.

  • The seller pays about $8,632 a year in property tax. In Florida the tax is worked out again after a sale, from what you pay for the home, so plan on a figure closer to this estimate.
  • This home is in a higher-risk flood zone, so a lender will require flood insurance.

Estimated monthly payment

$29,125

Principal and interest
$19,341
Property tax
$5,167
Home insurance
$3,908
Flood insurance
$708
Loan amount
$3,060,000

Estimates to plan with, not quotes. Tax and insurance vary by home and by insurer, and tax rules change. Doesn't include mortgage insurance. Your agent can get real insurance quotes and the exact tax figure.

Get pre-approved to know your exact budget

About the area

Looking up schools, restaurants, parks and drive times…

Similar homes

The multiple listing information is provided by the MIAMI Association of REALTORS® from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are © 2026 MIAMI Association of REALTORS®. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or renting. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Stay connected

Follow Us On Social Media

New listings, market updates and life in South Florida.