
$2.29M
4500 Sheridan Ave
SURPRISE LAKE, Miami Beach, FL 33140
Listing courtesy of The Corcoran Group · Jelena PA Khurana · 305-322-7089
About this home
Behind wrought iron gates and tall hedges, this 1928 Mediterranean villa offers a private garden retreat just five blocks from the ocean. Set on a 7,500 SF corner lot, the grounds feature Chicago brick walkways, a heated and cooled pool with a fountain surrounded by palms trees, and a covered patio for outdoor dining and gatherings. At its heart is a thoughtfully updated residence that preserves its original warmth and character. Windows frame the surrounding greenery and bring the beauty of the outdoors into the living spaces. Upstairs, the residence features two bedrooms (one currently used as a dressing room), a renovated kitchen and bathroom, a spacious living room with a fireplace, and an enclosed terrace overlooking the gardens and pool. Downstairs, an open-plan studio with it's own entrance and a private covered terrace, a full bathroom, and a renovated kitchen. It’s ideal for guests, a home office, or rental income potential while maintaining privacy for the upstairs residence. Just one block from Pinetree Park and within a few blocks of shops, dining, and La Gorce Country Club, this villa combines the privacy of a garden retreat with the conveniences of true Miami Beach living.
Details
- Type
- House
- Year built
- 1928
- Roof
- Ask your agent
- Insurers ask about the roof's age.
- HOA
- None listed
- Property taxes
- $9,827/yr
- Taxes usually change after a sale in Florida.
- Flood zone
- AE
- Higher-risk flood area. Lenders require flood insurance.
- Lot
- 7,500 sq ft
- Listed
- Oct 23, 2026
- MLS #
- A12112216
Run the numbers as a rental
Put in the rent and costs you expect.
Estimated cash flow
$7,814/mo
- Cap rate
- 10.4%
- Cash-on-cash return
- 14.6%
- Income after costs, per year
- $238,193
- Loan payment
- $12,035/mo
- Cash needed
- $642,600
Your own estimates, not a promise of any return. Cash needed includes about 3% for closing costs. Not tax, legal or investment advice.
What this home really costs each month
The mortgage, plus property tax as it will be after you buy, insurance for this home's roof and age, flood insurance if a lender requires it, and the HOA. Move any slider to use your own numbers.
The rate starts at 6.5% as an example, not today's rate. Move it to the rate your lender quotes you.
- The seller pays about $9,827 a year in property tax. In Florida the tax is worked out again after a sale, from what you pay for the home, so plan on a figure closer to this estimate.
- This home is in a higher-risk flood zone, so a lender will require flood insurance.
Estimated monthly payment
$19,635
- Principal and interest
- $13,055
- Property tax
- $3,463
- Home insurance
- $2,638
- Flood insurance
- $479
- Loan amount
- $2,065,500
Estimates to plan with, not quotes. Tax and insurance vary by home and by insurer, and tax rules change. Doesn't include mortgage insurance. Your agent can get real insurance quotes and the exact tax figure.
About the area
Looking up schools, restaurants, parks and drive times…
Similar homes
The multiple listing information is provided by the MIAMI Association of REALTORS® from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are © 2026 MIAMI Association of REALTORS®. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or renting. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.


