Skip to main content
Back to search
537 NE 96th St, Miami Shores, photo 1 of 20
For sale
1 / 20

$3.5M

537 NE 96th St

MIAMI SHORES SEC 4 AMD PL, Miami Shores, FL 33138

Listing courtesy of Compass Florida, LLC · Seth Long · 305-713-4100

4 bd 4.5 ba 2,757 sq ft

About this home

A one-of-a-kind architectural landmark, masterfully reimagined for modern living. The Gustav Weber Jr. House seamlessly blends timeless design with contemporary luxury, following a comprehensive two-year transformation by Shoreland Group, completed in 2023. Set on a lush double lot, this private tropical retreat features a 15’ x 30’ heated saltwater pool, specimen trees, bamboo garden, secluded lawn and expansive covered outdoor living area. Soaring 9’–14’ ceilings, oversized impact windows and skylights flood the interiors with natural light. The single-story main residence offers three bedrooms, complemented by a detached guest cottage with a fourth bedroom, full bath, kitchenette and separate laundry. The extensive renovation included reconstruction of the kitchen wing, a reconfigured floor plan, and new roof, electrical, plumbing, three-zone HVAC, impact windows and doors, skylights and insulation. Original oak floors complement new hardwood, Ann Sacks terrazzo marble, Clé cement tile, custom millwork and designer finishes. The chef’s kitchen features a six-burner BlueStar range and built-in microwave/speed oven. Rare city-supplied natural gas serves cooking, hot water and pool heating. Additional features include a dedicated laundry room, gated parking, underground utilities and curated gardens. A distinctive turnkey residence offering exceptional craftsmanship, modern infrastructure and resort-style living.

Features

  • Impact windows

Details

Type
House
Year built
1938
Roof
Ask your agent
Insurers ask about the roof's age.
HOA
None listed
Property taxes
$17,720/yr
Taxes usually change after a sale in Florida.
Flood zone
X
Lower-risk flood area. Flood insurance is optional but worth pricing.
Lot
13,000 sq ft
Listed
Oct 10, 2026
MLS #
A12103048

Storm protection: Impact windows. These can lower your insurance cost.

Run the numbers as a rental

Rental income

Put in the rent and costs you expect.

HOA: None listed

Estimated cash flow

$1,269/mo

Cap rate
6.7%
Cash-on-cash return
1.6%
Income after costs, per year
$235,480
Loan payment
$18,354/mo
Cash needed
$980,000

Your own estimates, not a promise of any return. Cash needed includes about 3% for closing costs. Not tax, legal or investment advice.

Get more deals like this sent to you

What this home really costs each month

The mortgage, plus property tax as it will be after you buy, insurance for this home's roof and age, flood insurance if a lender requires it, and the HOA. Move any slider to use your own numbers.

The rate starts at 6.5% as an example, not today's rate. Move it to the rate your lender quotes you.

  • The seller pays about $17,720 a year in property tax. In Florida the tax is worked out again after a sale, from what you pay for the home, so plan on a figure closer to this estimate.

Estimated monthly payment

$29,256

Principal and interest
$19,910
Property tax
$5,321
Home insurance
$4,025
Loan amount
$3,150,000

Estimates to plan with, not quotes. Tax and insurance vary by home and by insurer, and tax rules change. Doesn't include mortgage insurance. Your agent can get real insurance quotes and the exact tax figure.

Get pre-approved to know your exact budget

About the area

Looking up schools, restaurants, parks and drive times…

Similar homes

The multiple listing information is provided by the MIAMI Association of REALTORS® from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are © 2026 MIAMI Association of REALTORS®. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or renting. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Stay connected

Follow Us On Social Media

New listings, market updates and life in South Florida.